Residents of The Island Club Condominium concerned about $60,000 assessment

Article Courtesy of TCPalm.com

Published October 23, 2008 

JENSEN BEACH - An oceanfront condominium association is asking residents to pay an assessment that's about a sixth of the listed sales price of a typical unit in order to cover building repairs.

One resident, Ellen McKinley hasn't decided if she will pay the $60,000 charge at The Island Club Condominium. And she worries that some residents at the condominium will not be able to afford that amount.

"I hope that nobody will have to pay for this $60,000 assessment," said McKinley, a retiree who has lived in her unit for 12 years. "It depends on the outcome of the recall and how the board chooses to deal with the problem."

Residents of the 92-unit building were informed this summer that a forensic engineer has advised the condo board that the building's concrete needed repairs. Additionally, most of the building's original windows from 1978 also need replacement.

The condo association repairs that will likely total more than $5 million.

The $60,000 figure is about one-sixth of asking prices of $350,000 to $360,000 for a two-bedroom, two-bath Island Club unit on the Web site Condo.com.

The repairs are a matter of safety and the building's marketability, condo association president Donna Regenstreif said.

"We have been told that we have no choice," said Regenstreif, who has owned her unit for five years. "We legally need to do the repairs because the property is deteriorating. If they (replace the association board), they'll find themselves in the same pickle six months down the road."

McKinley is spearheading an effort to recall the condo board, which was elected in March. She said some residents cannot afford the assessment, and she's worried the association would place liens on units whose owners don't pay.

Those owners have had ample time to finance the assessment, Regenstreif said. Some owners have been offered grace periods and extended payments.

Disagreements over repairs are common between residents and homeowner associations, said Kenneth Direktor, an attorney with Becker & Poliakoff.

"There's always a few people that will not agree with you, said Direktor, who represents clients from Vero Beach to Miami.

Under Florida law, condo board members can be recalled, he said.

"All you need is a majority to have any or all of them removed," Direktor said.

A homeowner association needs to maintain the common property such as outer walls and windows to avoid sudden and costly expenditures like that at The Island, said Brad Hunter, who follows housing trends on the Treasure Coast and South Florida for Metrostudy's South Florida division.

"Looking for a scapegoat doesn't do anyone any good," Hunter said. "They just have to find the money to get this work done now."

CONDO ARTICLES HOME NEWS PAGE