The
Developer Sticks CDD #2 Residents
With the $127,000 Bill For Lago Bonito Synthetic Liner
|
The developer of The Villages threw a slap
in the face of the residents of CDD #2 when it told them to pay for the
Lago Bonito synthetic lake liner themselves. The developer has run
away from its obligations to maintain that lake area.
The $127,000 plastic liner was ordered
installed in the storm water run-off area, or retention pond, by the Southwest
Florida Water Management District (SWFWMD or, as it is commonly know, “Swift
Mud”). The liner was required to seal the pond bottom where several
sinkholes have repeatedly drained the polluted storm water run-off into
the underground aquifer.
The liner was installed in May. The
$127,000 cost will now be paid by the residents of CDD #2. Estimates
are that the cost per household will total about $40.00 as a one-time charge
paid out of funds collected from residents as part of their annual assessment.
Officials of the VCCDD and CDD #2 have
said that the funds are available in a reserve account to make the payment.
However, residents are actually paying the charge through annual assessments
that were either higher than otherwise needed in the past to build the
reserve account or will be higher than otherwise needed in the future to
replenish the reserve account. Either way, residents will pay the
$127,000.
Residents asked Nick Jones, the chairman
of CDD #2, to meet with the developer of The Villages to see if it would
consider paying all or part of the $127,000 cost. Mr. Jones reported
back to residents at the CDD #2 meeting on June 6, 2003, that the developer
said “no.”
The Rationale for the developer paying
the bill centers |
|
|
around the following points:
1. The developer charged the six
lot owners adjacent to the pond an average
of about $20,000 each, or approximately
$120,000 total, as a “lakefront lot
upgrade” premium when those lots were
first sold. One would have thought that
accepting the upgrade premium would obligate
the developer to maintain the “lake
” as promised. Instead, we now find
that the developer has reneged on that
promise and has taken the premium money
and has run away from its obligation
2. There is ample precedent for the
developer to pay for the liner as it has
done in several similar situations in
the past. In the cases of Lago Santo
Domingo and Lago Santiago, at the El Diablo
golf course, the developer paid the
full cost of installing a synthetic liner
into each of these lakes. In the
case of Lago Del Luna, by the De La Vista
golf course, the cost was shared by
the developer, the construction firm,
and residents. The developer recognized
its obligation to “make good” on its development
efforts for each of these
lakes. These precedents show recognition
by the developer of its obligation.
3. There is a significant public
relations aspect to this question. By not recognizing the obligation
to make good, the developer is damaging its own reputation for integrity
and fair-dealings with residents. If the developer is not fair with
residents after they buy into The Villages, can prospective residents trust
the developer to deal honestly with them on the initial purchase of a home
here in The Villages? Can residents trust the developer to deal fairly
with them on other issues, say, the sales of property to the VCCDD at a
reasonable price? Unfortunately, the developer’s actions here bring
up serious questions about integrity and honest dealings.
4. The developer might argue that
it was CDD #2 that built the retention area in question and therefore should
be responsible for maintenance and the liner if necessary. It may
be technically true that CDD #2 did the construction. However, construction
followed a plan designed by the developer of The Villages and formally
accepted by county officials. CDD #2 merely followed the plan formulated
by the developer. The responsible party is the developer.
In summary, the developer is ignoring its
responsibility for fair dealings with residents. The developer should
pay the $127,000 cost for the liner in Logo Bonito.
As a postscript, there are significant
questions about the quality and thoroughness of the job done by the construction
company in the installation of the liner. Some residents watching
the installation job noticed what appeared to be sloppy work for sealing
the existing sinkholes, spreading the ground around in an appropriate manner,
and dealing with rips and tears in the liner. Although the construction
company has extended the warranty to five years, sinkholes, new or old,
are not covered. It is hard to have a good feeling about this situation.
Also, residents throughout The Villages
should brace for similar charges for comparable pond repairs that the developer
will force upon them. The Villages is now being recognized as an
area of significant sinkhole activity. And, the developer seems to
have washed its hands of responsibility for the cost of pond repairs on
the properties in other areas of The Villages. Residents, hold on
to your pocketbooks!
Finally, what a disappointment this is
in The Villages. We always thought everything here was top notch
and that the developer was always going to stand behind us and do what
was right. Well, welcome to the real world – Obligations can be avoided
– and Buyer Beware.
| Annual
Villages Survey Is Much Too Fluffy |
The recent Villages Annual Survey has been
completed and the results published in the Daily Sun. This Survey,
conducted by The Villages and the VCCDD, showed that life in The Villages
is pretty nice and facilities are highly rated.
The problem is that the survey asks many
powder-puff questions, ignores many significant issues, and whitewashes
the results in favorable commentary in the newspaper.
The POA Survey printed in the Bulletin
used a survey technique that should be considered for the annual Villages
Survey. The survey asked for a numerical rating of between 1 and 10 for
each of 20 issues where 10 was the best rating. A selection of the
ratings is listed below. The POA’s comments and interpretations were
discussed in the February, 2003, issue of the POA Bulletin.
General Questions
Local FireServices
Emergency Health Care Services
Villages Taxi Service
Entertainment of the Square
Neighborhood Watch
Villages Media Group:
Villages Radio Station in General
Villages TV Station in General
Daily Sun Newspaper in General
Daily Sun Objectivity
District Administration:
Villages Central District Gov’t
Villages Administrator Performance
Villages Homeowner Organizations:
The POA in General
The VHA in General
The CIC in General |
Ratings
8.3
8.0
7.7
7.7
6.8
6.4
5.8
5.3
3.6
3.8
3.2
8.9
4.8
3.7 |
The results of this survey are more specific
and to-the-point in ways that The Villages survey never was. The
quantitative nature of the responses here allows a quick assessment of
the good points and problems.
Good points here are the factors rated
with a score of 7.0 or better. These aspects seem to be the ones
that Villagers are generally happy with.
Problem points are the factors rated with
a score of 5.0 or less. Now it is easy to see the problems.
Look at the list.
What are The Villages and the VCCDD going
to do about these problems? Perhaps they should acknowledge these
issues and focus on solutions.
At the recent meeting of the Sumter County
commissioners that considered the county redistricting question, Don Burgess,
president of the VHA, made an interesting comment.
In speaking against the map eventually
adopted for the redistricting, Burgess commented that it violated the principle
of “Taxation Without Representation.” He felt that Village residents
would be under-represented with just two of the five commissioners as the
map showed.
The POA would like to thank Mr. Burgess
for picking up on a phrase often used by the POA – that of “Taxation Without
Representation.” It is nice to see our message finally getting through
to the hierarchy of the VHA.
Now, the question is whether Mr. Burgess
would be willing to apply the same phrase to an equivalent situation right
here in The Villages.
Namely, the situation with the five supervisors
of the VCCDD who make most of the big money decisions in The Villages.
Residents cannot vote for these supervisors
because they are appointed by the developer of The Villages. And,
these supervisors like to commit Village residents to inflated-price purchases
of property from the developer. The recent purchase of $60 million
worth of property valued at only $10 million is a timely example.
Villages residents are then committed to
repay the bonds out of their monthly maintenance fee. And, guess
who would be on the hook to repay the bonds if the VCCDD ever failed and
defaulted on the bonds? – The residents personally.
If we cannot vote for or against these
free-spending supervisors, isn’t this a prime example of Taxation Without
Representation?
Would Mr. Burgess be willing to condemn
this example of Taxation Without Representation in The Villages?
He should.
Remember that we need material for this column
from our members. Send it to us and be sure to list your name and
address. Thanks.
JEERS – To the Union 76 gas station
on Hwy. 446 for its dirty outside areas. Can’t someone there sweep
up the place every now and then. This really reflects poorly on The
Villages.
JEERS – To The Villages maintenance
department for its lax mowing efforts over the past month. There
is foot-high grass in many common areas around The Villages. The
mowing frequency has to be increased when we have this much rain, especially
in common areas.
JEERS – To The Villages hospital
for making an urgent care patient wait 11 hours in the emergency room before
dumping the patient on another hospital for the require medical care.
This is shabby treatment by our hospital.
JEERS – To the street repair gang
patching a hole on Morse Blvd. in front of the Hacienda Country Club.
They had some leftover asphalt granules that had to be cleaned up from
the edges of the patch. Rather than pick these up for proper disposal,
they just pitched several shovels of these excess asphalt granules into
the grass.
The POA is pleased to announce that Fran Cagner
has accepted the position of Treasurer and Director of the POA. Fran
succeeds Betty Cunningham who recently resigned as Treasurer.
Fran came to The Villages 3 years ago from
New York state. She and her husband Joe live in Santo Domingo, CDD
#2. They were recently involved in the effort to line Lago Bonito
so as to prevent polluted storm water run-off from draining into the aquifer
through sinkholes.
Fran will assume her duties August 1st.
Please join us in welcoming Fran to her new responsibilities.
A week before the Civil War battle of Bull
Run, Sullivan Ballou, a Major in the 2nd Rhode Island Volunteers, wrote
home to his wife in Smithfield.
July 14,1861 Camp Clark,
Washington DC
Dear Sarah:
The indications are very strong that we
shall move in a few days - perhaps tomorrow. And lest I should not
be able to write you again I feel impelled to write a few lines that may
fall under your eye when I am no more.
I have no misgivings about, or lack of
confidence in the cause in which I am engaged, and my courage does not
halt or falter. I know how American Civilization now leans upon the
triumph of the government and how great a debt we owe to those who went
before us through the blood and suffering of the Revolution. And
I am willing - perfectly willing - to lay down all my joys in this life,
to help maintain this government, and to pay that debt.
Sarah, my love for you is deathless, it
seems to bind me with mighty cables that nothing but omnipotence can break;
and yet my love of Country comes over me like a strong wind and bears me
irresistibly with all those chains to the battlefield. The memory
of all the blissful moments I have enjoyed with you come crowding over
me, and I feel most deeply grateful to God and you, that I have enjoyed
them for so long. And how hard it is for me to give them up and burn
to ashes the hopes and future years, when, God willing, we might still
have lived and loved together, and see our boys grown up to honorable manhood
around us.
If I do not return, my dear Sarah, never
forget how much I loved you, nor that when my last breath escapes me on
the battle field, it will whisper your name...
Forgive my many faults, and the many pains
I have caused you. How thoughtless, how foolish I have sometimes
been!...
But, 0 Sarah, if the dead can come back
to this earth and flit unseen around those they love, I shall always be
with you, in the brightest day and in the darkest night ... always, always.
And when the soft breeze fans your cheek, it shall be my breath, or the
cool air your throbbing temple, it shall be my spirit passing by.
Sarah do not mourn me dead; think I am
gone and wait for me, for we shall meet again...
*************
Sullivan Ballou was killed a week later
at the 1st Battle of Bull Run.
*************
Taken from the TV series on The Civil
War by Ken Burns.
| Membership
Renewal Letters To Go Out Soon |
If you have not renewed your 2003 membership
in the POA, you should be receiving a letter from us within the next month.
Renewals so far have lagged, and we are hoping that this letter will jog
everyone’s memory. If you want to renew now, a 2003 Membership Application
Form is provided on page 4 of this Bulletin in the upper left hand corner.
Please complete all of the information on the form and return it to us
with a stamped self-addressed envelope. Thank you.
Why is it that the Daily Sun spends so much
effort and front page space on the working of the Lady Lake City Council
and the Lady Lake City Manager and so little effort on the monthly meetings
of the governments in The Villages, namely the VCCDD and the various CDDs?
Wouldn’t the situation in The Villages and the workings of our governments
be more important?
Lady Lake only accounts for about a third
of The Villages population. With the tremendous growth west of highway
27/441, the percentage is falling In 5-8 years the percentage could
be 10% or less.
So, why doesn’t the Daily Sun focus more
on the CDDs? For some reason or another, the Sun doesn’t seem to
think that resident need to know what is going on in their governments.
Why not?
April
Fools Day Revisited
(Don't Believe Any Of This) |
A Burlesque competition for the ladies will
be in the next Village Games and held at Katie Belle’s. Lingerie
will be provided by the recreation department. Bump and grind musicians
are being hired. Tempest Storm, a 74-year-old Village resident, who
still has “it”, will be the judge. |